- Tape will not stick dusty or greasy cases - adhesive will.
- Cases sealed with adhesive give greater security.
- Tape snaps = line downtime!
- Line stops to change tape rolls - adhesive level is constant.
- Lines can run faster with adhesive.
- Improved pack presentation - no tape.
- Potential board saving - case major flap width can be reduced.
- Safety - no sharp blades or awkward lifting positions.
- Tape Heads have very sharp knives to cut tape
- When replenishing tape, the operator must lean over the line to refill.
- Leaning over a line with moving parts
- Leaning over with arms extended and potential back problems
- Poor stacking
Based on one case size:
With tape = £0.00311 per case
With adhesive = £0.00218 per case
Saving per week @ 15 cases/min = £66.96
Above saving is on material only, also consider:
Compared to Tape, Sealing with Hot Melt Adhesive Lowers Long-term Operational Costs
Package sealing methods are all the same, right? Wrong!
While both hot melt adhesive and tape are capable of creating a bond and sealing a case, only hot melt adhesive systems deliver superior:
- Cost Savings
- Seal Quality
- Structural Integrity
- Ease of Maintenance
And only Interlock makes conversion from tape to hot melt adhesive sealing cost-effective and seamless.
The cost of different sealing methods can vary widely depending upon the length of the case, line speed and the price charged per pound of adhesive or roll of tape. While tape sealing may initially appear to be less expensive, hidden long-term costs can quickly erode any perceived savings.
The “hidden” costs of tape sealing
- Lost productivity and operator time replacing empty tape rolls.
- Increased material costs due to unusable tape rolls that have been damaged.
- Increased equipment expense to purchase additional tape machines in an effort to keep up with increasing line speeds.
- Increased downtime and parts costs associated with frequent maintenance of tape heads.
Tape requires special storage and handling
- Tape cracks or loses adhesion properties in cold, hot or humid conditions.
- Tape cores and edges can be easily damaged during transport.
Hot melt sealing keeps up with increased production, reducing investment costs
Interlock hot melt systems can easily accommodate an increase in line speed without additional hot melt equipment. Sealing 40 cases a minute is as easy as sealing five cases a minute, and even random size cases can be sealed automatically without additional expense.
Tape sealing systems are limited. As line speed increases, tension placed on tape can cause it to break and buckle, slowing production. Increasing speeds usually requires more durable, more expensive tape and tape heads or additional tape systems.
Hot Melt Adhesive Bonds Deliver Superior Structural Integrity and Seal Quality
Getting products to market requires cases to withstand extreme temperatures and humidity changes, abusive handling, potential tampering and rigid stacking and transportation requirements. Failure in one of these areas could result in damaged products and subsequent credit claims.
Hot melt adhesive, which penetrates the fibers of most board stock, is applied directly to case flaps, creating a strong, rigid bond resulting in a case that remains square and sturdy at all times.
Tape does not penetrate board fibers and only bonds the two external flaps, leaving the internal flaps loose. This weakens the load bearing capacity of the case, increasing the potential for costly product damage during transport.
Hot melt adhesive seals will cause the fiber to tear if any attempt is made to open the case before it reaches its destination, providing superior tamper-evidence and product protection.
Tape can be sliced with a knife. The products can be tampered with and the case resealed without the consumer’s knowledge. Tape provides inferior tamper-evidence and product protection.
Hot melt adhesive seals are hidden under the flaps and provide a clear surface to display expensive company logos and promote brand images.
Tape seals detract from and cover company logos limiting the effectiveness of brand images and messages. Clear tapes are more expensive. Tape seals can produce a “fly paper” effect. Static inside the case charges corrugated and dust particles which then attach to the adhesive backing on the tape seal. Retailers see this as “dirt” on the product inside and return the cases to the manufacturer.